These guys aren't even tryin' anymore...

 You could waste a lot of valuable time picking through the smouldering piles of intellectual rubble that get passed off as "news, views and analysis" on any given day over at Venezuelanalysis.com. Fortunately the news cycle generally serves up rather meatier fare than the thin, thin gruel those guys dish out, so I usually supress the urge to take down the artless propaganda that makes up the bulk of their oeuvre.

But the flesh is weak, so just this once I'll make an exception. Consider, if you will, this craptacular write-up on the FARC-ETA case - translated from an Aporrea original by something hilariously called "Axis of Logic" - where a certain Gonzalo Sánchez notes that all the major Spanish media outlets, including "Público, El País, ABC, El Mundo, La Razón, Cadena Ser, COPE, Libertad Digital as well as the TV Channels", gave prominent play to the story, and cites that as proof of..."an impressive and well coordinated smear campaign" against the Venezuelan government!

Sánchez (and the luminaries who translate and edit him over there) never seem to consider the possibility that some other, hidden factor might explain the bizarre phenomenon whereby a lot of different media outlets carry the same story at the same time even in the absence of a smear campaign. No alternative account for why that might have happened occurs to them, no conspiracy-free explanation for it is even intermittently entertained. The whole conceptual category of "news" simply eludes these people. 

By their reasoning, November 5th, 2008 witnessed the most fantastically well orchestrated media conspiracy in the history of humankind. Think about it, just about every single news outlet in the whole world led with the same story that day!

Coincidence?!  I think not!

Seriously, guys, I know the Culture Ministry took away your grant and all that. But c'mon, surely you can do better than this!

11 comments

How selective do you want to be?
 
   Santiago García

El laptop los tiene locos

Chavistas are still freaking out about Raúl Reyes' laptop? They must have come up with at least a dozen bogus reasons why it's totally fakety-fake now... :D

Anonymous 1
   Anonymous

Talking with a Chavista...

Talking with a Chavista is like talking to a Chinese man who just got off the plane in his first trip outside of China and whose understanding of the local language and culture comes exclusively form a tiny, poorly written English phrase book he bought in the Beijing airport before boarding his plane. He keeps trying to argue with you, but shows no understanding whatsoever of what you are saying or even what HE is saying, not even at the most basic grammatical level. You try using logic and reason and all he does is to repeat the same basic phrases over and over, all of which sound like they were written by a 5-year-old child, and seem to have absolutely no relation with the ongoing conversation ("Where is bathroom?" "Which way to hotel?!" "Where can sell mother-in-law to sexual slavery?!?!"), and he gets increasingly angry with you because you are not responding in the way that the little cartoon character in his phrase book says you should, so he cannot make the conversation go where he thinks it's supposed to go.

   jfombona

5th November

"Remember, remember the 5th of November"

Last fall I attended a faculty seminar intended to prepare participants for Žižec's upcoming visit (not quite my cup of tea, in part because I find him way too eager to play the diva-that-does-not-want-to-play-the-diva role), the group was a hodgepodge of hard core marxists, middle ground theologians, never-paid-income-tax anarchists and jesuits, all teachers in this red-state university. My guess is that another common characteristic, aside form reading the flavor-of-the-month philosopher, was that most were PSF. That aside, I made a remark about the 5th of November administration and the implied possibilities of change. I must say I have seldom sense such a collective "humph", a complete dismissal of what Obama might have meant. Yet the fact that grant monies paid for them to sit and ruminate on the coming end of Western Civilization and capitalism seemed to escape them...

My point, like the verdolaga, they are everywhere (although you can make a good salad with purslane and professors may give you hartburn).

   Quico

The thing that really rankles...

...is the smug posturing, you know, the "well-the-deluded-masses-might-buy-this-business-about-international-terror-plots-being-'news'-but-you-and-I-both-know-that-only-a-conspiracy-could-explain-this-rash-of-news-stories" pose. It's the self-satisfied glow with which deliriously non-sensical are arguments put forward in a site that bills itself - with no hint of irony - the Axis of Logic. 
It makes my soul ache...

Anonymous 2
   Anonymous

Point

The point is that they control the media and they don't have to come up with a good response. Thank God for the internet that gives us access to unapproved ideas.

Anonymous 3
   Anonymous

And by that same logic...

Every time that every single Chavista outlet - including Aporrea and Venezuelaanalysis - carries the same story, it's proof positive of "an impressive and well coordinated smear campaign" BY the Venezuelan government.

AIO

   butbutbut

well of course

Anonymous, that's the whole point -- these people live and work as part of a well organized media campaign in which "news" shows are just a slightly different format for showing the same message. While the Chomskyian analysis of advanced capitalist news is that it ends up being just as censored, it's not really the case that there are, for example, direct orders from the White House, or even from the editor in chief, about just what to cover -- "cover the Dow Jones average, skip the Palestinian peace rally" is not the content of the memos. On the other hand here there are direct orders from the information ministry to be sure to cover X, and those memos get amplified on their way down through the burocracy to the point that VTV "news" is just a half-hour exercise in condescencion and mockery.

Anonymous 4
Anonymous 5
   Anonymous

Yep, the chavistas really

Yep, the chavistas really must think we're all idiots and they're the only ones who have the keys to the truth. I worked for a chavista for a while, and they really live in their own little world. Thank you for your blog and keep up the struggle. Saludos desde Honduras.

Anonymous 6
Add new comment

New here?

For a gentle introduction, read the Beginner's Guide to the Chávez Era.
 
To get the most out of comments, take a minute to create a free account.

Join The Fray

  • RECENT COMMENTS
  • MOST COMMENTED
  • BEST OF THE FRAY
1 . The opposition should condemn Uribe (updated)
Posted on: 1 week ago.
Total comments: 95

2 . It's the Racketeering Stupid (or, How the Opposition Should Play This Thing...)
Posted on: 6 days ago.
Total comments: 56

3 . My name is Francisco and I'm a blog-o-holic...
Posted on: 6 days ago.
Total comments: 55

4 . The guru
Posted on: 3 weeks ago.
Total comments: 47

5 . "Your child can't have that operation because we need the money to capitalize SIDOR"
Posted on: 1 day ago.
Total comments: 47

6 . Occam's razor
Posted on: 1 week ago.
Total comments: 36

7 . Chabuki watch #6
Posted on: 3 weeks ago.
Total comments: 34

8 . Venezuela Responds to Colombia's Allegations of Collussion with the Guerrillas
Posted on: 1 week ago.
Total comments: 28

 

Navigation

Twitter

Daily Delivery

Enter your email address:   

  

 

English Blogroll

The Devil's Poop: Miguel Octavio's comprehensive Venezuelan news blog
Daniel's Blog: The view from Ruritania
Kepler's Blog: Venezuela, meet Europe. Europe, Venezuela.
Global Voices Online: Worldwide blog roundup: Venezuela page.
OilWars: Once chavista, now wobbly lefty blog.
21st Century Socialism: Calvin Tucker's cybershrine to chavismo and the Soviet model.

Spanish Blogroll

Blogs de El Nacional: Featuring Hernán Lugo Galicia's PSUV gossip blog Política de Ñapa.
Panfleto Negro:
Literary mass blog, open to all comers.
Los Cuadernos Azul y Marrón: Vicente Ulive-Schnell's cantankerous rambling.
Radar de los Barrios: Chuo Torrealba's innovative innitiative on Caracas's shantytowns.
Ana Julia Jatar's Blog: Wonkish stuff
Webarticulista Collective opposition opinion blog
Sin el chivo y sin el mecate: the students come of age
Capuchino: Father Jesus Garcia's unique perspective from Kavanayén, Edo. Bolívar
La Silla Vacía: The view from the sister republic

English Links

VenEconomy: Venezuela's leading bilingual business magazine, and Quico's former employer.
El Universal in English: Not very well translated news from EUD.
Google News: Top Venezuela stories.
The Latin American Herald Tribune: Successor to the venerable old, now defunct, Daily Journal.
Miami Herald: Venezuela Page.
Financial Times: Americas Page
Human Rights Watch: Venezuela Page
Amnesty International: Venezuela Page
Francisco Rodríguez @ Wesleyan: Top resource for economic research into the impact of the Chávez era
Organization of American States: Venezuela Page
Venezuela Information Office: Our tax-bolivars at work - government-run pro-Chávez blog aimed at the US
Venezuelanalysis.com: Most sophisticated pro-Chávez site.

Spanish Links

Noticias 24: The granddaddy of Venezuelan news aggregators, plus insane bulletin boards.
Twitter #Venezuela: Micro-blogging site's Venezuela stream.
TalCual: Newspaper edited by the legendary Teodoro Petkoff. Subscription required and worth it
El Universal: "Serious" Caracas daily, strongly opposition minded.
El Nacional: The other "serious" Caracas daily, strongly opposition minded
Globovision: Opposition run 24 hour news station. Text news free, Windows Media Video by subscription.
Union Radio Noticas: News portal and streaming audio.
GoogleNews Venezuela: Venezuela GoogleNews portal in Spanish.
Ultimas Noticias: Tabloid edited by Eleazar Díaz Rangel. Chávez-friendly. Subscription.
Descifrado: Opposition financial gossip site. Some items free, others by subscription.
El Chigüire Bipolar: Closest thing Venezuela has to The Onion. Very silly. And hysterical.
Notiven: News digest + links to dozens of Venezuelan newspapers.
ODH Grupo Consultor: News monitoring and economic analysis.
Urru.org: Massive oppo archive
E-lecciones: Fascinating selection of polling power points, international observer reports, and other election related stuff
Agencia Bolivariana de Noticias State news agency: all chavista propaganda all the time
Aporrea.org: Website of the Asamblea Popular Revolucionaria. Militant pro-Chávez site, occasionally critical of the government
VTV - Canal Ocho: State TV. Hardcore propaganda. Live WindowsMedia work only sometimes
Panorama: Maracaibo newspaper, privately owned but aggressively pro-Chávez
teleSUR: Hemispheric arm of the chavista propaganda machine
Viejas Fotos Actuales: Fun archive of historical pictures, films and audio recordings
Provea: One of Venezuela's two most respected human rights' NGOs
Cofavic: The other one of Venezuela's two most respected human rights' NGOs
Human Rights Watch: Venezuela Page
Central Bank of Venezuela: Good starting point for economic and monetary data.
Finance Ministry: data.
El Librito Azul: Constitution of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela - 1999

Frontline on Chávez

Frontline's genius 2008 documentary on the Chávez era. (Versión en español aquí.)

Email Us Directly

To get in touch with us directly:
Quico: franciscotoro at fastmail dot fm
Juan Cristobal: nageljuan at gmail dot com

Law of the Land

A documentary shot in 2002 and 2003, contrasting the experiences of two Venezuelan farms taken over in the name of the revolution.

Venezuela - Spanish with English Subtitles. Produced by Francisco Toro, Directed by Megan Folsom.


Click to watch full screen
Running time: 60 minutes.

Syndicate

Syndicate content