Everybody knows the answer, right? With gas fetching just a few US cents a gallon, it’s a no-brainer: “a lot!”
Let’s take Simon Romero’s Low but not Crazy-Low $9 billion estimate in the New York Times. If that’s about the right figure, it’s hard to convey just how mind-blowingly, absolutely head-spinningly crazy and impossible to justify it is.
Let’s try to put that number in perspective: Brazil has become a world leader in poverty alleviation schemes through Bolsa Familia, which hands a mere $13 per child per month to the mothers of the poorest quarter of the population.
With its much smaller population, Venezuela could afford a program with similar coverage and similar payments for about $430 million a year. (The math is simple: Venezuela has around 11 million under-18s. A quarter of that is 2.75 million. Multiply that by 13 dollars a month, then again by 12 months in the year to get to $430 mill.)
Killer Fact: $430,000,000 is just 5% of the NYT-estimated cost of the gas subsidy! One twentieth!
With the money we now waste on this fat giveaway to the middle class, we could afford Conditional Cash Transfers worth $135 a month for fully half of Venezuela’s children. That’s about Bs.580 per kid – meaning a poor mom with three kids would stand to make over Bs.1740 a month just by keeping them in school and making sure they get their health check-ups on time. Of course, until we can pin down the real cost of the gas subsidy, these numbers are speculative.
I know what you’re thinking: any proposal to do away with gas-subsidies remains politically toxic in Venezuela. That’s why Chávez still hasn’t dared to touch them.
But leadership is about making people aware of the choices they face.
A gas-subsidy-financed Bolsa Familia could eradicate child poverty in Venezuela within a couple of years. It will take a leader to make that choice clear to people: to establish the trade-off in people’s minds. Because once that linkage is made, once you show people with deeds, not words, that what they get in return for higher gas prices is a guarantee that no single child will ever grow up in extreme poverty again, you “fix the moral economy” of the gas subsidy, making its elimination politically viable on a lasting basis.
[Hat tip: Moraimag.]
Addendum: How far out of whack are Venezuela’s gas prices, in international comparison? This far out of whack:
You’d have to multiply our gas prices by a factor eighteen just to bring it into line with the second most heavily subsidized gas market in the hemisphere!
Hat tip: an accompanying post from Setty. One nifty idea in his post – on Earth Day in Brunei, people are forced to pay international prices, just to see how out of whack their regular prices are.
Caracas Chronicles is 100% reader-supported.
We’ve been able to hang on for 21 years in one of the craziest media landscapes in the world. We’ve seen different media outlets in Venezuela (and abroad) closing shop, something we’re looking to avoid at all costs. Your collaboration goes a long way in helping us weather the storm.Donate