Juan is right. Comments-via-Email probably does run counter to some deeply ingrained Venezuelan cultural values. That’s a singularly bad reason to oppose it, though, just like Venezuelans’ deep cultural attachment to cheap gas is a terrible reason to oppose a gas price hike.
A good deal of what’s deeply ingrained in Venezuelan (or any other) culture happens to be bullshit – and this affectation of radical intellectual egalitarianism strikes me as a key example: one important aspect of the proverbial por eso es que estamos como estamos.
I come to bury deeply ingrained BS, not to praise it.
Now, is the Sullivan model viable for a straight, elitist, Venezuelan-turned-Canadian snob?
I don’t know.
That’s not just some rhetorical crouch, a politico’s dodge to avoid telling an angry mob that Comments-via-Email are here to stay. I genuinely don’t know how the dynamic of the blog is going to evolve under the new system. I don’t know if we’ll get enough postable email to keep the community vibe going. I don’t know if the overall reading experience is going to improve or deteriorate. I don’t know if readership figures are going to increase or decrease. I don’t know if we’ll have more, better discussions or fewer, worse ones.
One thing I do know is that a blog is a living, breathing entity. It seems kind of crazy to me to try to decide if the new system works or not before you’ve seen it in action. Until we give it a few days to settle and readers get a chance to try out the new feel of it, to experience its joys and miseries first hand, how can you possibly tell which outweighs which?
So I’m proposing a kind of moratorium on comments-about-comments. Let’s just put this debate in amber for a couple of weeks and return to it when we have some basis for judgment. Until we do, I don’t really see the use of it…
Caracas Chronicles is 100% reader-supported.
We’ve been able to hang on for 21 years in one of the craziest media landscapes in the world. We’ve seen different media outlets in Venezuela (and abroad) closing shop, something we’re looking to avoid at all costs. Your collaboration goes a long way in helping us weather the storm.Donate